BUTLER TOWNSHIP DUPLICATE FOR EXTRA TAX - 1851
| SURNAME | GIVEN NAME | PAGE | NOTES |
| RAMSY | William | 24 | |
| REED | Augustus | 25 | |
| RENO | John | 24 | |
| RENO | Peter | 24 | |
| ROBISON | Joseph | 24 | |
| ROBISON | Thomas | 24 | |
| ROCHO | John C | 25 | |
| SALMON | Snow | 27 | |
| SARVER | Jacob | 26 | |
| SCOTT | Mitchell & David | 26 | |
| SHAFER | Leonard | 27 | |
| SHAFFNER | Jacob | 25 | |
| SHANER | Daniel | 25 | |
| SHORTS | Washington | 26 | |
| SHORTS | William | 26 | |
| SHRADER | John | 26 | |
| SHRADER | Peter | 26 | |
| SHULER | Luke | 25 | |
| SMITH | Christian | 25 | |
| SMITH | George | 26 | |
| SNYDER | Christian | 26 | |
| SNYDER | Jacob | 26 | |
| SNYDER | Jacob Jr | 26 | |
| STEWART | James M | 26 | |
| STEWART | Robert | 27 | |
| STOKE | Christopher | 27 | |
| STOKE | Faldon | 25 | |
| STOOLFIRE | Philip | 26 | |
| STRAWICK | David | 25 | |
| SUGART | Jacob | 27 | |
| TROUTMAN | Adam | 27 | |
| UERE | Balse | 27 | |
| VANERY | Nicholas | 28 | |
| VARNEY | Emil | 28 | |
| VOGAL | Philip | 28 | |
| VOGAL | Tobias | 28 | |
| VOGAL | William E | 28 | |
| WAKEBAKER | Henry | 29 | |
| WALKER | David | 29 | |
| WALLACE | William C | 28 | |
| WALTERS | Daniel | 29 | |
| WALTERS | Jacob | 29 | |
| WALTERS | Philip | 29 | |
| WATTS | James M | 29 | |
| WEAVER | Peter | 29 | |
| WEAVER | Samuel | 29 | |
| WEBER | Adam | 28 | |
| WHITE | Eli | 29 | |
| WISE | Anthony | 28 | |
| WISE | James M | 29 | |
| WISEMAN | Gotleib | 28 | |
| WOLFGANG | Charles | 29 | |
| WRIGHT | James M | 28 |